About Us
Steffey Insurance compares quotes from leading carriers to save you time, energy, and money.
- Serving clients since the 1970s
- 25+ licensed agents
- Offices in Indianapolis, Cincinnati, and Philadelphia
- Nationwide coverage
Real Guidance Where You Need Us
We operate offices in Indianapolis, Cincinnati and Philadelphia allowing us to serve clients with a strong local presence across each region. Our agents live and work in these communities, bringing a clear understanding of the risks and needs specific to each area.
In addition to our core locations, we are licensed across the country in nearly every state including Illinois, Kentucky, Tennessee, Delaware, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, and Virginia.
Wherever you are and whatever stage of life you’re in, our goal is simple: to provide reliable guidance, thoughtful coverage, and the confidence that you’re properly protected when it matters most.
Real Insurance Guidance Trusted By Thousands
For more than four decades, clients have trusted Steffey Insurance to help them navigate complex coverage decisions with clarity and confidence.
Very happy with my experience. I first did business with Steffey Insurance Agency nearly 5 years ago and Thomas Edney cut my car insurance rate in half. Now I'm in the process of purchasing my first home and Carlye Bertwell was able to secure me a great price on my homeowners insurance. Highly recommend!
I couldn’t be happier with the exceptional service provided by Jennifer Beardsley! From start to finish, she made the entire insurance process seamless and stress-free. Jennifer is not only incredibly knowledgeable but also takes the time to thoroughly explain options and ensure everything is tailored to your unique needs. Her responsiveness and genuine care stand out in an industry where those qualities can be hard to find. Whether you're looking for advice or a customized policy, Jennifer goes above and beyond to make sure you're covered. Highly recommend her to anyone seeking a trustworthy and reliable insurance agent!
Jennifer Beardsley is amazing! She walked me through a very tough insurance renewal process over the holidays. I felt totally supported and benefitted greatly from her patience and experience. Highly recommend! So thankful to be with quality people like this!
I have been dealing with this Steffey for about 4 or so years, they handle all my insurance needs including my business as well. They always seem to find me fantastic pricing and have been great to deal with I would recommend them!
I am so grateful for the communication, care, best-value insurance policies (Auto and Home)! Allison Morse, Personal Lines Manager has always got my back. I'm particularly compelled to write this review because this time last year I was rear-ended on the expressway. My precious car was totaled - and Erie Insurance (best bet for me, via Steffey) recovered my $1,000 deductible for me. THAT doest not usually happen. You're in good hands with Steffey Insurance Agency!
Steffey Insurance Agency provided outstanding service from start to finish. The team was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely took the time to understand my insurance needs. They explained all options clearly and helped me choose the best coverage at a fair price. Communication was fast and friendly, and any questions I had were answered without delay. It’s rare to find an agency that combines efficiency with such a personal touch, but they managed to do exactly that.
What Makes Us Different
Independent guidance, not tied to one carrier
We work with multiple insurance providers, allowing us to compare options and recommend coverage based on your needs
Experienced Advisors
With more than 40 years of experience, our team knows how to simplify complex insurance decisions.
Clarity When You Need It
Not sure what coverage you need? Our advisors walk you through the options and help you make confident choices.
Ongoing Support
From policy setup to claims assistance, we remain your partner long after the initial quote.
Let Us Take Insurance Off Your Plate
We believe in finding the best insurance solutions tailored to your unique needs. This means no more hours on hold, confusing documents, or wondering if you got a fair deal. For over 40 years, we have been comparing quotes across top carriers nationwide so you get the best coverage at the right price.
Ready to let us handle your insurance for you? Share what matters most to you and we’ll handle the rest.
Know someone who needs peace of mind?
When someone you refer becomes a Steffey Insurance client, we'll send you an Amazon Gift Card delivered straight to your email. It's our small way of showing how much your trust means to us.